I am not a fan of co-sleeping. The "family bed". But I always wonder if it is humanistically natural for the whole damn fam to sleep in one spot. Probably, right? We are social animals after all.
It isn't like cavemen had Serta Pillowtops soft enough to drown their babies, or down comforters that were so light and fluffy that they could float over and adhere to little noses. Or Ambien. Or weight/alcohol/drug problems. Or one of the other millions of reasons that The Man tells us not to put baby in bed with us. They just hunkered together for warmth and protection and slept.
During the newborn months, I never felt like I could have (godforbid) saved Jake from choking or whatever faster if he was in my bed with me than I could if he was in the bassinet right next to me. As for nursing, it was just as easy to lift and latch that kid as it was to roll over and position. Plus I was sleeping better because I wasn't worried about crushing my baby with my boob that was twice as big as his torso. If there were gasping sounds or a fire alarm or this or that or the other, Jake was right next to me, but in his own little sleeping space. Safe from harm. I could get to him in two seconds.
Not that it didn't kill me to be six inches from that kid.
I thought I had it bad then.
Boy was I wrong.
It really pains me now not to sleep next to Jake. It really slays Jake not to sleep next to me. He cries and begs, I deny and try not to let the lump come out of my throat and through my tear ducts.
I love that kid so much and I miss holding him for hours and hours each day and I feel like if I could just curl up with him every night my life would be so much happier and he would be so much more pleasant and moon beams would dance on our cheeks and a rainbow would appear each morning to wake us and bluebirds would sing on my sill and baby deer would take their first wobbly steps down my hallway on their way to get a drink out of the toilet.
But supposedly it's not very mentally/physically/emotionally healthy for anyone to pile up into the big bed, according to Big American Standards.
Plus I like my own space. I'm sure I'd be ready to give him the boot by 1am each night when he had is foot in my windpipe and his sticky hand tangled in my hair.
I think it's weird that we get our own beds all through childhood and then you are expected to share them when you meet someone special. I think it's weird that we get our own rooms our whole lives, then when we move in with someone, we have to share. That's disgusting and unfair. But that's not the point. Or maybe it is. Maybe we aren't supposed to have so much personal space all the time. Maybe we should be near our people. Our pack. Our pride.
Am I really ruining Jake for life if I fall asleep with him at night? Probably not. I'm sure he will want me out Out OUT! of that room soon enough. I doubt he will need me to come into his dorm room and hold him "just five minutes more".
Am I ruining myself? More likely.
In those squishy warm warm classes that I take for professional development (teaching teachers how to teach parents how to parent, essentially. There are about 1000 hours of parenting/child development classes available to us. Which has saved my hide more than once) we learn to caution caregivers to be sure that they aren't filling a missing void in their lives by forcing affection on their children or bribing their children to be close to them.
Gah, I don't want to be that parent but I see how easily it can happen. I don't want to fill that elusive hole in my heart with my child's presence. It isn't his responsibility to make me feel better. It's my responsibility to get better so I can be sure that I am there to help patch his holes. To be a better mom. To enjoy time with him, rather than use time with him.
I don't want to obsess over the horror stories I hear each day and try to repair my soul by holding Jake tight against me while he sleeps. That's creepy.
Effective, but creepy.
So even though it is hard for us both sometimes, bedtime is still amazing. And most nights I make it out of there before one or both of us falls asleep in his tiny little toddler bed that seems to be shrinking by the day. And I can go in there and check on him and touch his face and cover his toes whenever I want during the night. And Jake will likely grow up to not be a serial killer who victimizes people who remind him of mommy. I might do some growing up of my own.
And everyone will be happy and not grossed out by our wacky family.
3.24.2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

21 degrees {comments}:
also, I think I want to do a little independent internet research on the methodology used for these studies that say co-sleeping prevents SIDS. I suspect their definition of co-sleeping includes children in the same ROOM as parents, not necessarily in the same BED.
I used to do a lot of reading on all this stuff while I was pregnant the first time. What I found out is that there is a lot of evidence to support whichever side you are on. I think we just do what works for us.
I personally enjoy NOT having my kids in my bed. I like snuggling up with my kids for ten minutes while we read stories and sing songs but then we hug and kiss and part ways.
Let us know what you decide!
there will be no bed sharing, or room sharing! it's just hard to say goodnight sometimes.
I slept with Parker when she was a newborn b/c it was easiest while nursing. I loved her tiny warm body, even if it was taking up my precious space.
I cannot stand to sleep with her now. She sleeps sideways, feet in my kidneys, all the while trying desperately to hijack my pillow.
I miss the sweet cuddly days.
There's this notion that Americans don't co-sleep, only whacky Europeans or "primitive" cultures do. I think it's bunk. Take a survey of how many moms fall asleep in their kid's bed. Ask how many kids crawl over to the parents' bed.
For us, we had an attachment-impaired child and co-sleeping was the key that unlocked his heart. Physical proximity is one of the keys to bonding right? We all know about Harlow's Monkey.
I love my kidneys and hate to see them bleed from billions of karate kicks through the night, therefore, Duke sleeps in his own bed despite how badly I want him to snuggle with me...
It eats at you and makes you feel guilty either way you look at it... Either I'm a dick for not letting him cuddle with me all night, or I'm a dick for letting him sleep with me and become oddly dependent on me to fall asleep...
I'm such a selfish dick for needing my own space but I don't care... I bought the king size bed for me, not for a nightly slugfest/sleepover!
We have some serious sleep issues at house de pj. Night terrors, and teeth coming in and a beans being a master manipulator at age two. She falls asleep and wakes in the middle of the night yelling no no no, then she finishes the night off in our bed. Heartbreaking to her your kid screaming no in their sleep. We have chatted about this before and this post and comments are great to read.
Eric didn't have a bedroom until he was 3 so he either slept in his crib in our bedroom or in our bed. I loved having him sleep with us, my Husband not so much (Eric kicks). Then my husband worked nights for awhile and I didn't want either of us sleeping alone. Then my Husband got laid off and Eric had to go back to sleeping in his own room. It sucked, he didn't fight it but we both missed snuggeling. Now we have "hang time" and I lay with him on non-school nights until he falls asleep. I love it.
Sleeping babies are so sweet...in their own bed. Beau didn't sleep with us when he was a newborn, but then it got so easy to bring him into bed with us in the middle of the night, and that was our major mistake. Even though he got out of that habit and was sleeping through the night in his own bed, he now opens his door, walks across the darkened house in the middle of the night to our room, where he stands on the side of the bed with arms outstretched. Inevitably he ends up between us, sideways, of course. I love him, but don't like him sleeping in our bed.
I go back and forth thinking that it's odd that a baby goes 9 months in such confined quarters, only to be born one day and have to sleep on their own, and thinking that they're babies and that's just the way it is.
That book "I'll Love You Forever" was probably the creepiest thing I ever read. Until my baby became a boy and I realized that sometimes the only time he'll allow for snuggling is when he's almost asleep. And god help me if I ever get stuck, but I haven't found the strength to tell him "no" when he asks me to "Sweep wif me to 60." So I curl up beside him and we count to 60 and sometimes we count to 60 again and again. And then he gives me butterfly kisses and somehow his eyelashes are strong enough to brush away all the crap of the day. And then I can go to my bed all happy and mothery.
Nicole didn't sleep with us very often, but now? well sometimes she sleeps in her own bed.. other times shes on a matress pallet on the floor in the den where my hubby usually is asleep on the couch. He doesn't sleep in our bed very often becasue of his back and the surgery he had on it - just not comfy. But when she wants so sleep with mommy in my bed? nope can't stand it, lol. The last time i agreed? she got sick and barfed all over my bed - hasn't slept with me since - I don't do vomit...
( and thanks for the book recommendation - will proabaly order it off amazon next payday!)
I didn't co-sleep with Turner. He was in a bassinet by the bed for about 8 weeks and then we moved him into the nursery. He slept better and we slept better. He's not much of a snuggler but sometimes he turns into a baby before bedtime and he wants to be wrapped in a blanket and held like an infant. He has nights when he wants a "ba-ba." I give in and play along because he's becoming an independent boy so fast and he knows how much he loves his independence but I feel like a part of him misses the dependancy sometimes. He likes to have me take care of him and and he likes be needy and sometimes I like to take care of him like a baby and feel needed in that way. He is growing up and won't want to play these games anymore and I'm sure I will miss them and be glad I played along. I'll put these memories in my happy bank to be used during difficult times like when he leaves for college or during my diaper changes in the nursing home.
OMG. The baby deer. The wobbling first steps. The toilet. I am dying. DYING.
We're one of those families in which the child is in our bed pretty much every night. It's a rare occurence when he's not. We'd prefer he slept in his own bed so my husband and I could actully get a good night's sleep but alas it hasn't happened that way. My story sounds exactly like pj (earlier commenter in this thread). In a strange way I do like snuggling with him and I probably will miss the day when he no longer sleeps with us. Truth be told I'd rather he be in his own room but I'm a pushover and seriously sleep deprived. At this point if sleeping in our bed stops the middle of the night screaming when he wakes every hour to find himself in his crib then I'll continue to share my pillow for a bit longer so I'm not a complete walking zombie.
We never really let Tyler sleep in the bed with us (granted, you've got a couple years on us, so who knows what will happen in the future), but he did sleep in a bassinet in our room for about 3 weeks. After that, we put him in his crib and closed the door. I love this routine, but I long for the day that Tyler naps with me.
We had a nephew that my sil could not get out of her bed once they let him in. With our oldest we said "Crib from day one." He was a great sleeper. The 2nd was a preemie, so tiny, quiet cries, so he slept in the bassinet by our bed for awhile. But still not in our bed. My idea of a good night's sleep is not worrying about crushing my baby and contorting around their little bodies. I like to spread out.
Lora- Cooper is baffled by the fact that he has to sleep alone and we get to sleep with each other. It really is bizarre when you think about it! And no explanation seems to make him understand- he still thinks it isn't fair. We talk all the time about how we could have saved a ton of money by buying a house with fewer bedrooms.
We snuggle at bedtime and then he crawls into bed with us in the morning- 15 minutes a day seems to give us all our fix!
Do what works for you- and don't be afraid to wave your "freak flag" proudly.
:)
I'm glad Josephine would rather be in my bed than her own because I love having her there...but I have long thought that any future husband would be better off agreeing to seperate bedrooms.
We never really got into the whole co-sleeping thing when she was an infant, although she did sleep in the same room as us until she was about six months old. Sometimes if she is sick I'll take her into bed with us, but then I CANNOT sleep because I'm afraid I will crush her (how I will crush a 25-lb toddler without her lettimg me know it, I don't know). Also, she kicks a lot and generally doesn't sleep very well when she's in our bed. That said, when she's a little older and asking to sleep with me - well, that's a whole different ballgame. I can see how it would be hard to resist.
I have had this same discussion with so many of the parents that I used to work with in CA, where "Attachment Parenting" is a really, really popular parent methodology. The whole idea of us being the only mammal that expects our young to sleep alone is wild...not to say that I don't enjoy and need my space, however it is truley for my and Cody's own selfish reasons, not necessarily because it is "best and healthy" for my child.
I seriously don't even want to co-sleep with my husband.
Seriously.
And he's, like, awesome.
I always want my own bed and I have long thought that it is ludicrous that when you get married, you have to share.
Post a Comment