Does your town make a giant deal when eighth graders complete the school year? Mine does. It's the stupidest thing I've ever heard of in my entire life. Eighth grade graduation? Please. I've never heard of such a thing until I moved to Philly.
I understand Pennsylvania is a bit behind the times. But not a century behind.
I understand I live near Amish country, where kids are only expected to go to school until they are teenagers. But not in it.
Nothing says "yer ass ain't gonna walk crossed no high school stage so we may aswell make a big deal bout this now" like making your gangley weirdo 13 year old put on an ill fitting polyester cap and gown and parade them around the middle school before taking them home and serving rigatoni and hoagie trays and cake to everyone you've ever known in hopes they bring greeting cards full of dollars.
Then again, in all fairness, for some reason people make a big deal out of everything in Philadelphia. I say it gives people a warped sense of pride and self confidence. I can't be proud of someone for doing something they are supposed to do. Was it Chris Rock who says something about how you aren't supposed to go to jail and you're supposed to take care of your kids? I think it was.
If you are operating somewhat normally and able-bodied, you're supposed to go to school. For at least twelve years. You're supposed to learn how to read. And do math. And get a job. And sit up by the time you are one year old. And start talking by the time you are in kindergarten. And brush your teeth. And wash your hands. And pee in the potty. And and and. This city (and the world, I'm sure) is full of little brats who think they are so damned special and unique when all they are is a normal kid doing normal kid stuff but their mothers have nothing better to do than decorate their front windows (oh yes, houses are all-out decorated for communions and graduations and everything in between- probably more elaborately than most people decorate for Christmas. I'll get some pics this weekend to prove the redunkulousness) and throw a blockparty to celebrate every tiny milestone their kid passes. And those brats grow up with a sense of entitlement and importance that ends up getting them nothing and nowhere. And then they pass the same thing on to their normal boring vanilla kids who think they are Very Special and Not Boring. And so on and so on and so on.
I can't be part of that.
I walked into my building this morning behind a girl dressed in a pink sweatsuit that had the word Princess sprawled across her butt. It was bedazzled. As were her nails. And her flip flops. And her cell phone. And her fake Louis Vuitton bag. And she got mad when someone let the door close rather than holding it for her despite the fact she was walking at a snail's pace and 15 feet behind the entrance. And she stuck her lip out, which was barely visible under her ridiculously large MaryKateLike sunglasses. And she was at least 40. Or maybe she slept in a tanning bed at night and just looked at least 40.
I know that girl. Not her, exactly, but her. That girl is like cockroaches round these parts.
Seriously though, these kids might not make it through high school. Less than half of high school students graduate in this school district. And we are not the worst off city in America, not by a long shot. And rural areas can be worse. I think instead of turning Going to Ninth Grade Next Year into some sort of Second Coming we should work on keeping them for the next four years.
Not telling them about the FACTS of sex and condoms is clearly not working to prevent pregnancy and the resulting drop out rates. Or STDs. STDs aren't prevented by silence.
Just Saying No to Drugs and ignoring the signs of use and addiction isn't keeping kids from getting high and cutting school.
Passing kids despite failing grades isn't helping the matter. Learning disorders are ignored. IEPs are ineffective and are becoming a generic form for everyone rather than an Individualized pathway to learning. That's what the I stands for. Individualized. Let's do it.
Ignoring truancy or giving a slap on the wrist isn't enough. Have you met the mothers of some of these kids? They think school is stupid. They most likely dropped out by age 15 so they are completely stuck at age 15 for the rest of their lives. I've been in enough homes and schools and family court hearings to know that this is the prevailing attitude in way too many households. These moms and dads don't need a job, they are doing just fine. Just ask them.
They don't need school, they are smart about things they need to be smart about. Just ask them.
Yeah, no. Trust me when I tell you that if I've been in your house between the hours of 9 and 5 and the days of Monday thru Friday, you aren't doing fine. Your unemployed, undereducated ass should never even know me. If we know each other, you aren't doing just fine.
Women are raising their daughters to find husbands rather than find themselves.
Men are raising their sons to be tough rather than real men.
Beauty and stuff is prized before knowledge and ambition.
This extends beyond color, beyond class, beyond neighborhoods.
But please, let your kids drop out and fall into the system. If they do, I am guaranteed a job. I love my job. I want to keep it. And they are pretty much guaranteed to raise their kids the same way, so I can work long past retirement age now that everyone practically has too.
What the hell am I even talking about? Do I realize that it's not even 9am?
I might be a bit roiled up.
I'm going to go take a zen like walk around the block and start this morning anew.
I'm either drinking too much coffee or not enough.
I need to stop paying so much attention to everybody else and start minding my own business.
I need to stop caring about other people's habits, even if they are the people that live near my son and will potentially be his peers and their parents in a couple short years when he goes to school when he starts to model their behavior and bring that crap home with him and HEY! Dammit.
I need an island.
6.03.2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)


26 degrees {comments}:
Please don't stop caring about other people's habits, then I'll have nothing to read in the morning! :) And I think that all of these graduations are out of control. My mother-in-law teaches preschool and they have a graduation every year. Seriously, the full deal - caps and gowns and songs and everything. I don't remember this sort of thing from when I was a kid.
I'd like to share that island.
Things out where I am are so different. I don't think I could live in the city. I love hearing your stories and love, love, love your Urbanity blog.
I totally agree with you that kids should not be rewarded for stuff they are supposed to be doing! It's so sad.
I don't think Grade 8 graduation is a big thing here. There is definitely a ceremony and maybe a dance for the kids, but I've never heard of anyone decorating their homes or even throwing parties for the occasion.
I remember kids getting new bikes, etc. for "passing" (i.e. not failing the grade). I thought it was a good idea and asked my parents about it. They told me, in no uncertain terms, that those who rewarded their kids handsomely for that which they were supposed to do anyway were setting the bar low for their children. I tell my kids the same thing. We come from good high-expectations stock.
LOL I had 8th grade graduation, but it was more like an awards banquet. We got awards for attendance and stuff, had a sit down dinner in the school cafeteria, then a dance in the gym afterward. We thought we were cool.
Good luck with that island. I spend every September, October, and November de-bratting my kid when school starts again. Yep, it takes that long.
The title of your post is so perfect, as are all your observations. Did you see today's Inquirer story on the importance of asking someone to the prom in a jaw-dropping manner? Apparently this arms race started because of some stupid TV show set in Orange County. It's not enough to just verbally extend the invitation, which used to be hard enough. Now you have to one-up everybody else in your school when you pop the prom question. Why aren't people expending this kind of energy on important stuff? I despair.
We did the 8th grade graduation thing in the teeny tiny town I grew up in. It was a big deal at the time -- I got to wear pantyhose for the first time, make-up, heels, and I even got to get my ears pierced for the occasion. Looking back, it's a kinda creepy to realize how very much it was like a "coming of age" celebration. The dance after the graduation ceremony was a little awkward... when you've gone to school with the same 17 people for the past 8-9 years, slow dancing to Chicago in the lunchroom/gymnasium/all purpose room feels a little like tongue kissing your brother. Look Away, indeed.
I'd love to know how many the Dolores County kindergarten class of '82 traded a handshake for a sheepskin in '94 and how many continued to add bits of paper to the collection.
What the hell? 8th grade graduation? only the catholic school does that in Bellevue, and that is because they think they are better than everyone else. They are snobs for the first week of high school, till they figure out that the teachers don't care that they went to catholic school until high school...then they get over themselves. I vote "yes" for this island...we can ban sweatsuit outfits with writing on the bum!
I am not as freaked out by 8th grade graduation as I am by kindergarten/preschool graduations. Of course, I just threw a party for my oldest son's preschool graduation so I'm not a model of consistency here. But their "graduation" didn't feature caps and gowns and celebrated everyone, even the three year olds who will be back for two more years, so it was more of an end-of-year party.
What I am thinking of doing for balance is a Start-of-School-Year party. That's what's important after all.
OTOH, the kindergarten doesn't do anything big here but the elementary schools do. I think I'm all about the rite of passage (communion, etc.) but not about dressing it up like something it isn't (like an actual academic degree that was completed).
My husband used to teach in a school for former dropouts. The kids were furious that he didn't come round them up for class when they were late from lunch or the computer lab and blamed them for being late. He stood them up and walked them to the computer lab and pointed to the clock. Then he walked them to the lunchroom and pointed to the clock. Then he looked at them and said, "Six year olds can tell time. I respect you too much to treat you like five year olds. Read the clock."
It was never a problem again. And many of the other teachers, who kept doing roundups, never understood why my husband didn't have to.
I live in the heart of Amish country where kids literally "graduate" when the finish the 8th grade. No parties. No celebrations. The public schools where I live don't celebrate them neither. This is a first and I agree, what the eff. Really?
Wow, at 50% dropout rate, that's pretty high. I agree that it's unnecessary to make a big deal out of minor scholastic achievements--or in this case, supposed milestones that aren't necessarily tied to achieving anything. Why do we applaud people for fulfilling the status quo?
8th grade! Try kindergarten graduataion! I know a kid who may or may not be related to me not by blood thank you jeebus who got an ipod for "graduating" from fifth grade!
So, next year I will be faced with the rigmarole associated with Claire's "graduation" from pre-K. I find it utterly ridiculous...I mean, who doesn't graduate from Pre-K except the kids who don't bother going? It's not like you need that degree to get into kindergarten. So the kids will be going their separate ways, why not a good bye party, or a glad you were here while you were here but now it's time to go to real school party? Anyway, i am reiterating what you and the other commenters said. My main point is what to do, what to do? I think it is stupid so do I prevent Claire from wearing the cap and gown and walking across a stage in some mock celebration of achievement? Or do I go along with it because she will be disappointed? And if I go along with it (sobbing like an idiot in the audience, I am sure) where is the line? Will I allow Gavin to rent a helicopter to invite his date to prom because big and obnoxious is the only way to get a princess-sweatpant-wearing chick to say yes? When the time comes, will you send Jacob across the stage with tears in your eyes because (gasp!) he managed to finish 8th grade?? How do we stop the madness??
Let's talk about Lily's preschool graduation, complete with caps, growns and diplomas. While she was the most adorable thing I have ever seen in her costume, it may have been the most ridiculous thing I have ever experienced and I have had a lot of ridiculous experiences.
Where I live in Arizona we have 8th Grade Promotion which I think is stupid.
That dropout rate is depressing. Right now, right here, our educational system is depressing, the views of some of the people I'm close to regarding education is depressing, and "Princess" bedazzled on anyone's butt is the most depressing.
I'm all for islands.
Well, that pretty much summed up how I've been feeling about all that for quite a long time. We're giving our kids a sense that every little thing they do should be celebrated. Sadly, when they get out in the real world there will be very few people who will jump and shout simply at their mere existence.
I feel this way about schools trying to make sure every student gets an "A". Just doing the work should not warrant an "A" grade. We're teaching our children that they have to do very little to get the biggest rewards. It's time we give them a dose of reality - celebrate only that which is outstanding and not that which you should be doing anyway. And only the very best deserve an "A". Not everyone is a straight "A" student but our kids are convinced they are ALL geniuses. That is until they go to college where real professors don't pamper you and out to work where companies don't care about you and will fire you if you can't get the job done because there are at least 1,000 other 'geniuses' waiting in line for that job.
And please don't get me started on the whole South Philly/South Jersey words written on your ass look. As a girl who grew up in South Jersey I saw this look every day and all it screamed to me was that you looked cheap. (And I don't mean that as in frugal.)
I write about this all the time!! I really thought it was a huge problem in the suburbs but I see that major cities are following suit or maybe have always been doing it too.
If you have time check out some of my rants.
http://tinyurl.com/p5dr5y
http://tinyurl.com/qq6po
http://tinyurl.com/pytxqr
I know that looks like a lot but believe me I have a lot more. It is a sore subject with me too!
I think our town has a graduation for each grade level? WTF?! Back in my days (am such an old lady now) we graduated ONCE when you completed the 12th grade.
Im with Memgrl and WRH -- putting little toddlers in cap and gown is Jonbenet icky. Ive seen this for kindergarten graduation and it FREAKS me out.
On that island thing - a fun game to play. You are on an island and you are allowed to have 5 different people on with you. And the you also have "swimmers" who swim around the island and come on only when you call because there are parts of them you cant live without but there are other parts that are so annoying you will send them back to swim around the isalnd soon enough. Fun game - especially when you limit your choices to men only.
I think your coffee intake is just right.
OMG, I've been out of it for a few weeks and I just read your last five days of posts! I don't know where to start, except, don't stop talking, whatever you do!
I'm a burb mom, and sick and tired of little sixth graders losing Ipods and studded cell phones, which both were in their damn little Vera Wang purses!
I went to 9th grade when there were teridactyls (sp?) still flying around. We actually had a graduation and dance. I think they held it because we were all getting split up among three different high schools. Some of these kids were never seen or heard from again!
You've had a great week so far. Keep it going!
You are singing to the choir, sister. Preach on!!
In the first middle school I taught (1989) 8th grade graduation floored me. Girls in prom dresses and boys in tuxes. Limos dropping them at the door and balloons and flowers being delivered all day long. It was a very poor working class area. Some of these kids were more educated than their parents. And it was very sad and depressing to watch.
Ive been doing some teaching this week and its left me so frustrated. I know 13 and 14 year olds think they know everything, and i certainly did, but they dont realise i am giving up my time for them to talk and scribble instead.
I think all kids should try to teach before they leave school so they see how it feels!
/rant over!
And then I get these entitled, apathetic precious snowflakes in Grade 13, where they think that they should get As for effort. Sigh.
Tomorrow is my Tink's K graduation. I'm not buying the video.
Heh, lurved this post. They made a huge deal out of it at my school. Ooh, moving from grade 8 to 9, big whoop. Also, at high school, cap and gown was too gauche. Guys wore tuxes and girls wore full length white dresses and carried roses. I'm not even going to wear that on my WEDDING.
Seriously woman...this post was great! But I do want you to know that you are not alone in Philly. I certainly had an 8th grade graduation in the great state of Illinois and they made a big deal about. Looking back I realize the school district may have totally encouraged that for the reasons you listed...but at the time I was excited to get a new dress. I don't know what you do but I am glad you do it! And the girl in the pink sweatsuit...I think she is brilliant because she provides comedy to my life. Its sad but yes I am laughing at her. She would have tried to beat me up in high school and make me feel like I was stupid or unworthy...karma is a bitch isn't it?
I saw a girl wearing a "Juniors '09" shirt last week. I didn't get it. Since when did they start celebrating 11th grade and making/buying shirts about it?
Post a Comment